https://youtu.be/gVmZQk1_RMw?t=1m28s
I am not bringing this up to deride or disparage Justin Trudeau's command of English, since he possesses a high level of bilingualism that most of us can only envy.
Rather, I find it an interesting question: why DO we say "air" and not "hair" for "heir", especially considering that the etymologically related "heritage" and "inherit" are both pronounced with "hair"? One can never accuse English of being consistent!
"Heir" is in fact one of only four words in standard English (along with their derivatives) starting with a silent "h:. The other three are "honest", "honour", and "hour" (in some varieties of English, "herb", "human", "huge", and "humour" are also on the list). These prove particularly tricky for francophones, who never pronounce "h" in their own language and work very hard to do so in English...only to discover that we've stuck some into our language that aren't pronounced. It must seem like a wily trap, especially for those making solemn oaths in front of millions of people.
All these words share the same history, tracing back to Latin words written and pronounced with an "h". In the case of "heir", the Latin word was hēres. By the end of the Latin era, though, the initial "h" was no longer pronounced, so when Latin evolved into Old French, the word became eir. Legal terms were one of the big categories of words we borrowed from the Normans, so English acquired "eir". No "h" in the pronunciation or the spelling.
But in the Renaissance, there was a move in English to reflect the Latin origins of our words by re-inserting letters into the spelling that had been there in Latin but had long since been lost. This phenomenon accounts for many of our silent letters (for links to other examples see the end of this post). "Eir" became "heir", but we still didn't pronounce the "h".
"Inherit" and "heritage" travelled the same path, starting out in Middle English as "inerit" (ultimately from Latin hērēditāre) and "eritage" (ultimately from Latin hereditagium). Under the combined influence of mass literacy and the social opprobrium reserved for English speakers who "drop their aitches", we started pronouncing the re-inserted "h" in "inherit" and "heritage" (as well as in many other words like "humble", "history", "habit" and so on). But we never did so, oddly, with "heir". How long can "heir" keep up this rearguard action before it succumbs to the pressure of analogy, which in its case is threefold:
all the other words in English starting with "h"
all the other words that have reacquired the Latin "h" in their pronunciation
its etymological cousins "inherit" and "heritage".Perhaps Justin Trudeau is just a man ahead of his time.
Other silent letters in English (click on the links):
"h" in "school" and "schedule"
"h" in "Katherine" and "Anthony"
"g" in "reign"
"p" in "ptarmigan"
"c" in "muscle"
P.S.
If you find the English language fascinating, you might enjoy regular
updates about English usage and word origins from Wordlady. Receive
every new post delivered right to your inbox! If you are not already
subscribed, you can either:
use
the subscribe window at the top of this page
OR
(if
you are reading this on a mobile device): send me an email with the
subject line SUBSCRIBE at wordlady.barber@gmail.com
Privacy
policy: we will not sell, rent, or give your name or address to
anyone. You can unsubscribe at any point.
Follow
me on twitter: @thewordlady
in some (rather old-fashioned) dialects of British English 'hotel' and sometimes 'hospital' may be pronounced with a silent 'h' as well.
ReplyDeleteIt has always been perfectly normal then that some people pronounce the “h” in Montreal, at least. In the days of confessional schools, Montreal had two English public school boards – a Protestant one and a Catholic one. The Catholic schools had students primarily from the Irish and Italian communities. Anyone who came out of the English Catholic system pronounces the silent “h”. When spelling out something, they pronounce the letter “haitch”.
ReplyDelete"haitch" is a pronunciation that is commonly found in Ireland and areas of Irish settlement/influence. In Australia too you can distinguish the Catholics from the Protestants by how they pronounce "H": the former "haitch", the latter "aitch". I didn't know this was also true of Montreal.
Delete